Every Monday I open the bank balance and hope.
Story · Case study
One network review a week instead of one a quarter
Route economics used to be a quarterly project with a start date. It is now an operation the planning team submits on Monday and reads before lunch.
The company
- Company
- Kestrel Logistics
- Industry
- Logistics
- Company size
- 1,001–5,000 people
The starting point
Kestrel Logistics runs 1,900 vehicles out of fourteen depots. The economics of that network — which routes earn their cost, which depot should take which drop, what a closure would do to the rest — were reviewed once a quarter by three analysts over about five weeks.
The review was thorough and the network moved faster than it. By the time a recommendation was agreed, two of its assumptions had changed: a customer had renegotiated, or a depot had taken on volume it was not sized for.
What changed
What they described
Kestrel's head of network planning described the review rather than the tool: what makes a route economic, how a drop is costed when two depots could serve it, what counts as a fair allocation of fixed depot cost, and which constraints are real (driver hours, vehicle type) versus habitual (a customer who has always been served from one depot).
Separating those two was most of the value, and it came out of writing the description down rather than out of anything the platform did. Several of the constraints the analysts had modelled for years turned out to be habits nobody had questioned since a depot opened.
The results
The scenario that paid for it
A depot lease came up for renewal at a rent Kestrel considered indefensible. The question — what happens to the network if we do not renew — had previously been a four-week study, which meant it was never asked until the lease was nearly expired.
It was submitted as model-depot-change on a Tuesday afternoon. The answer said the closure was
survivable, that two neighbouring depots absorbed most of it, and that eleven routes became
uneconomic in a way that would need renegotiating rather than absorbing. The negotiation that
followed used the eleven routes as its opening position.
Routes scored each week
1240
Cost per drop
-4.8%
against the same quarter last year
Routes flagged late-risk
31
Days to a network review
1 day
from five weeks
“A quarterly answer to a weekly question is a wrong answer three times out of four. That was the whole business case.”
— Declan Moss, Head of network planning, Kestrel Logistics (an example business)
The apps
What it cost to run and what to expect
What the planning team says about it
That the weekly rhythm matters more than the model. A slightly worse answer every Monday beats a better answer every quarter, because the network's questions arrive weekly and an answer that arrives after the decision is not an answer.
Connected to this story
Read next
Why: Day in the role, with an example app you can try today
Tell me when it's ready
What happens next
Thank you. We will write once, when it's ready.